Hi Oliver! Thank you for creating this game. It has brought my friends and I many hours of fun during quarantine. :) We're wondering if there's any chance you would consider adding the Hong Kong Old Style Scoring Variation 3? That is the style we learned from our parents in Hong Kong and is the style we are most familiar with. We would appreciate it very much. Thank you! http://mahjong.wikidot.com/rules:hong-kong-old-style-scoring -Fish

Fish, thank you for the message. I would consider adding old hong kong rule.

Hi, Fish, I finally got time to add the Hong Kong Old Style Rule Varation 3. I have uploaded it. Please enjoy if you find it fine, or let me know if there is any bugs! Cheers,

what is the difference betwwen old style and what was there before?

Hong Kong Style: variation 2

Hong Kong Old Style: variation 3

Both rules are online.

Old rule: the score items are different, and the payoff is power of "Fan", while the payoff of new rule is just "Fan".

See link above for details

Thank you so much, Oliver! We will try it out tomorrow night and let you know!

Hi Oliver! We tried out the Old Style Variation 3 today and the scoring looks good! Unfortunately, there seems to be a bug when someone clicks the Win button, the buttons disappear, but the game does not continue and is stuck. The games that froze were 14896 and 14898. I've attached snapshots of the 2 hands that froze. In the first pic, "Overdrive - West" was trying to win and in the second pic, "fish - West" was trying to win with the 1 Circle. Thanks in advance for looking into it!

Also would like to send my thanks! I was able to reproduce it with bots just now. I'm trying to win off "Bot 422 - South" after they discarded the "80000" tile. This is game 14910, hand 3 (the stuck game does not get recorded unfortunately) with a minimum score of 3.

Thank you for adding this variation!

Hi, Fish & monkeytacos!

Thanks for your feedback. I tried a few hands and it went well. So I suggest it was the browser cache. Please try press "Ctrl + F5" in the game page to reload the whole page, or you can manually clear the cached files of this site. Let me know if it still does not work.

Thanks Oliver.

I tried it again with CTRL+F5 in the game page, and inside a game, and also opening up chrome dev tools and selecting disable cache in the network tab. I still was able to have it hang immediately after I press the win button available unfortunately.

minimal score is 3. In this hand, I got the 7-sticks on my draw (it disappeared right after I press win, so that's why it isn't in the screenshot). I think I should have won with 7 points (1 for self win, 3 for semi pure, 1 for all chi, 2 for honors)

I'm not sure what the problem is. Could it be hanging after reaching N number of points?

strange. i played a few hands with chrome and firefox on my phone, it was fine. hand id 1110498.

not sure what the problem is...

strange indeed...

I've played a bit more on a different browser (Edge) and I'm also able to reproduce it. I see it in higher value winning hands (e.g. 6 or higher)

on a separate note, I recently won with this and I believe it is missing the "all chow" or "all chi" 1 point, so instead of 5 points, I only got 4.

Thanks!

If it helps, "winListener" on line 1660 is called while "win" on line 1118 isn't when it hangs.

I'm almost convinced it is on hands that are 5 points or more that causes the game to freeze.

that was impressive, mankeytacos!

I cannot make a hand with 5+ fans with random initial hands. Then, I made a hand with arranged initial hand and it went fine.

I will try more later

Thanks Oliver, I'm out of ideas then :)

hi, monkeytacos, if you would like to: when you find it stuck, press F12 to enter the debug interface, and click the "console" tab. Then click the button in the game that causes the stuck, there should be some error information, usually in red. That may help.

Unfortunately, I don't think there's much info there in the console logs:(

For this game:

I won, with the discarded '50000' tile by bot214, 1 point for honor, 1 point for wind, 3 for half flush.

and this was the console logs

(All levels of logging was on)